social computing

Don’t Sweat the Social Hierarchy

Don’t Sweat the Social Hierarchy

In our previous post, Enable Social Tagging, we looked at using social tagging sites to raise your site’s profile. In this post, we enlarge on our theme from Social Media is the Megaphone and talk about social media as a conversation among equals.

Sweating StatueAttributionShare AlikeSome rights reserved by quinn.anya

Don’t Sweat the Hierarchy

We’ve been quoting social media pundit Seth Godin in the last couple of posts and continue here, on the topic of modes of social media communication. Godin stresses that, since the nature of social media is distributed, non-hierarchical, and definitely not top-down, command-and-control, this have can implications for how your business is organized. He states that the huge non-profit United Way has underperformed in the last decade, and looks to the way they are organized as one of the keys.

The United Way is a classic top-down approach. By creating arrangements with the Fortune 500, they were able to do payroll deduction on millions of paychecks. That, all by itself, was key to their scale. But what happens when those relationships aren’t as important? Because people rarely talk about the United way and its work, the word of their great efforts doesn’t spread as far and as fast as it might. As a result, it’s hard for them to catch up when the payroll-deduction approach loses juice.

Compare this to the brilliant peer-to-peer gimmick embraced by Nike and Lance Armstrong. […] [T]he Armstrong LiveStrong idea spread so far, so fast precisely because of their side-to-side, not top down approach. In our ever faster, ever more selfish world, the chances of growing a non-profit with a top down approach are tiny. It’s just too hard, we’re to busy and you don’t have enough time or money.

Consider Godin’s recommendations along with ours as you prepare to engage with your community.

Give the Megaphone

Ask your supporters to commit. This goes beyond the kind of commitment represented by merely buying your product. Make it easy for your supporters to pick up the megaphone and tag your site, blog about it, “Like It” on Facebook,[1] +1 it via Google, tweet it on Twitter, and so on.

You’d be surprised how effective committed supporters can be:

  • Dell estimates[2] that a Dell detractor costs the company $57, and a promoter generates $328
  • A study across 20 brands by analyst firm Syncapse[3]found:
    • The average annualized value of an individual fan on Facebook is $136.38; the range is from $270.77 in the best case to $0 in the worst
    • On average, fans spend an extra $71.84 they would not otherwise spend on products they describe themselves as fans of, compared to those who are not fans.
      • McDonald’s saw the largest variability, with Fans reporting spending $159.79 more per year than non-fans
      • Oreo saw the lowest value with a difference of $28.52
  • Fans are 28 percent more likely than non-fans to continue using a specific brand
  • Fans are 41 percent more likely than non-fans to recommend a product they are a fan of to their friends
  • An average fan may participate with a brand ten times a year and will make one recommendation. But, an active fan may participate thirty times and make ten recommendations.
  • On the other hand, social media management firm Vitrue found that a Facebook Fan is worth $3.60 of media value
    • Vitrue determined[4] that on average, a fan base of 1 million translates into at least $3.6 million in equivalent media over a year at a $5 CPM (meaning, that a brand’s 1 million fans generate about $300,000 in media value each month)

Of course, there are lots of ways to give your supporters the megaphone, and we cover many more techniques in the chapters that follow.

The key is to give the megaphone, not hog it.

Next up: Measure Social Media Results


Don’t Sweat the Social Hierarchy is the 36th in a series of excerpts from our book, Be a Person: the Social Operating Manual for Enterprises (itself part of a series for different audiences). At this rate it’ll be a long time before we get through all 430 pages, but luckily, if you’re impatient, the book is available in paper form at http://bit.ly/OrderBeAPerson and you can save $5 using Coupon Code 62YTRFCV

See the previous posts What is Social Media?, Social Sites Defined, Why Social Media? How is Social Media Relevant to Business? First Steps Toward a Social Media Strategy, and Decide What Your Business Will Do About Social Computing, pt. 1


[1] Add a Like Button – Facebook Developers: bit.ly/xdHEfs

[2] Dave Chaffey: bit.ly/cA0uLs

[3] Gigaom’s How Much Is a Facebook Fan Really Worth? bit.ly/pw924D Link to the report PDF: bit.ly/mV67os

[4] Real Time Marketer’s A Facebook Fan is Worth $3.60. Really? bit.ly/pNPe9K A dissenting view from The Future Buzz’s More Absurd Social Media Analysis – The Value Of A Fan bit.ly/oi6QD7

Enable Social Tagging

Enable Social Tagging

In our previous post, Social Media is the Megaphone, we took a look at enabling your community to speak. In this post, we examine using social tagging sites such as Digg and delicious to enable your community to find you.

TaggingAttributionShare AlikeSome rights reserved by cambodia4kidsorg

Enable Social Tagging

A good way to enable your community involves social tagging.

There are lots of social tagging sites, but three of the most popular are Digg[1], del.icio.us[2] and Reddit.[3] Social taggers who find an interesting Webpage can easily tag it — mark it as interesting for other site members to see. Only a minority of people actually tag pages, while a much larger number cruise the tagging aggregator sites looking for interesting topics and pages. This gives the taggers an enormous influence for their size.

Encouraging your community to tag your information and media can dramatically improve your visibility, even if your site does not perform well in Google searches. Seth Godin did a search on “diabetes” on Delicious. The search led him to a site filled with white papers on diabetes.

While this site would likely not show up on the first page of Google results, because eight people had tagged that page, Godin was able to easily find it through social bookmarking. Therefore, instead of spending vast amounts of time and resources on SEO techniques to influence Google search results, if an organization can manage to get even a handful of their advocates and supporters to tag their pages, their visibility on the net would increase dramatically.

Godin puts it like this:

The Acumen Fund [a non-profit global venture fund working to solve the problems of global poverty] has hundreds of pages on its site — yet most of them are essentially invisible. If the organization made it easy for donors and supporters to start tagging pages, the most important messages would rise to the top. The same thing is true for art museums, religious groups and the ACLU. In every case, there are pages, buried and doomed to decay into obscurity. But if a few surfers tagged the pages appropriately, though, other surfers would find it. And the word would spread. The big secret of del.icio.us is that the percentage of users who do the tagging is tiny. Most of the traffic to the site is looking for the tagging done by a tiny minority. This is the essence of online leverage.

Think about how you can leverage your supporters by encouraging social tagging. It’s a great way to drastically improve the impact of a small group of supporters.

Next up: Don’t Sweat the Social Hierarchy


[1] Digg: bit.ly/9T3tk4

[2] Delicious: bit.ly/ceCC9I

[3] Reddit: bit.ly/ceCC9I


Enable Social Tagging is the 35th in a series of excerpts from our book, Be a Person: the Social Operating Manual for Enterprises (itself part of a series for different audiences). At this rate it’ll be a long time before we get through all 430 pages, but luckily, if you’re impatient, the book is available in paper form at http://bit.ly/OrderBeAPerson and you can save $5 using Coupon Code 62YTRFCV

See the previous posts What is Social Media?, Social Sites Defined, Why Social Media? How is Social Media Relevant to Business? First Steps Toward a Social Media Strategy, and Decide What Your Business Will Do About Social Computing, pt. 1


Social Media is the Megaphone

Social Media is the Megaphone

In our previous post, Social Media Relationship Stages, we took a look at the process of drawing your audience into a closer relationship. In this post, we talk about enabling your community to speak.

RenegadeAttributionShare AlikeSome rights reserved by Richard Masoner / Cyclelicious

Social Media is the Megaphone

And your supporters are the speakers. Encourage them to:

  • Tag you on delicious.com, digg.com
  • Upload relevant photos to flickr.com
  • Blog about you
  • Tweet about you

Seth Godin describes the power of the Internet, and of giving your supporters the megaphone:

The Internet changes everything. Now, one person armed with a keyboard can reach millions. One person with a video camera can tell a story that travels around the world. And one person with a blog can sell a lot of computers.

The trick is this: you need to give your fan club some leverage, an amplifier — a megaphone.

Your former patrons, the aggrieved ones, the critics — they’ve already found the web. They’re the ones who have managed to post play-by-play accounts of your misdeeds and missteps. They’re motivated and they’re already embracing the medium.

A diligent marketer, however, can make it easy for your fan club to get the word out as well. And to do it in an authentic, uncontrolled, honesty way.

This is why you don’t censor comments about you online: There are supporters as well as detractors out there. If you get all paranoid about nasty things the haters (or trolls) say, and feel tempted to remove them, it helps to remember that your supporters see these posts as well. And if you’ve enabled them — handed them the megaphone — you may find they’ll rush to your defense.

This won’t work, however, if you insist on approving all posts on sites you control.

Doing so stifles the ability for your supporters to quickly respond to negativity. It also breaches the trust you hope to establish with your community. If community members feel they must think twice before posting — taking into account whether Big Brother will approve their posts — you lose the ability to find out what they really think, and violate the implicit contract you established with your community when you decided to engage with them.

Next up: Enable Social Tagging


Social Media is the Megaphone is the 34th in a series of excerpts from our book, Be a Person: the Social Operating Manual for Enterprises (itself part of a series for different audiences). At this rate it’ll be a long time before we get through all 430 pages, but luckily, if you’re impatient, the book is available in paper form at http://bit.ly/OrderBeAPerson and you can save $5 using Coupon Code 62YTRFCV

See the previous posts What is Social Media?, Social Sites Defined, Why Social Media? How is Social Media Relevant to Business? First Steps Toward a Social Media Strategy, and Decide What Your Business Will Do About Social Computing, pt. 1


Social Media Relationship Stages

Social Media Relationship Stages

In our previous post, Ask for the Commitment on Social Media, we discussed asking your community for a commitment. In this post, we examine the process of drawing your audience into an ever-closer relationship.

Social Media Relationship Stages

RenegadeAttributionShare AlikeSome rights reserved by Ed Yourdon

To encourage a relationship with your customers and prospects through social media, it will take more than placing a simple “Buy” or even a “Like” button on your home page or social media site. As we’ve discussed, one of your online goals should be to draw existing and potential customers into a relationship that will be productive for both parties. The basic steps, to paraphrase online marketer Seth Godin, are to:

  • Turn strangers into friends
  • Turn friends into customers
  • And then… do the most important job: Turn your customers into evangelists

The trick is to do this without resorting to traditional marketing tactics that may turn off your online community.

Traditional marketers refer to the gradual process of enticing the public to become buyers as the marketing funnel. Lots of folks go in the top; only a few fall out the bottom as customers. Godin thinks this metaphor is all wrong for online marketing. In his free e-book targeted at non-profits Flipping the Funnel — Give Your Fans the Power to Speak Up,[1] Godin gives advice that enterprises can benefit from as well:

The math is compelling. Most of the people in the world are not your donors [customers]. They haven’t even heard of you, actually. And while many of these people are not qualified buyers or aren’t interested in supporting your organization, many of them might—if they only knew you existed, if they could only be persuaded that your offering is worth investing time and energy and passion and money into.

But how on earth are you going to get them to know about you?

We’re living in the most cluttered marketplace in history. Whether you are curing cancer, encouraging faith or educating people in need, people are better at ignoring you than ever before. You don’t have enough time to get your message out.

Godin goes on to say that most organizations have underused assets: your friends and your supporters.

Godin’s idea is to flip the marketing funnel and turn it into a megaphone. You give the megaphone to your fan club: the people who like and respect you, and who have a vested interest in your success.

Next up: Social Media is the Megaphone


Social Media Relationship Stages is the 33rd in a series of excerpts from our book, Be a Person: the Social Operating Manual for Enterprises (itself part of a series for different audiences). At this rate it’ll be a long time before we get through all 430 pages, but luckily, if you’re impatient, the book is available in paper form at http://bit.ly/OrderBeAPerson and you can save $5 using Coupon Code 62YTRFCV

See the previous posts What is Social Media?, Social Sites Defined, Why Social Media? How is Social Media Relevant to Business? First Steps Toward a Social Media Strategy, and Decide What Your Business Will Do About Social Computing, pt. 1


[1] Flipping the Funnel — Give Your Fans the Power to Speak Up: bit.ly/9r3Psa


Ask for the Commitment on Social Media

Ask for the Commitment on Social Media

In our previous post, Your First Social Media Contributions, we discussed how to make your first contributions on social. In this post, we get into a serious subject: asking your community for a commitment.

RenegadeAttributionShare AlikeSome rights reserved by Dave Duarte

Ask for the Commitment

“Social Networking that matters is helping people achieve their goals.
Do it reliably and repeatedly — so that over time people
have an interest in helping you achieve your goals”

Seth Godin

You’re using social media for a reason. You want something. It may be attention; it may be sales; it may be brand awareness. The best-designed social media sites feature calls to action — click to get our newsletter; click to find out more; click to buy.

Your site should ensure that your audience knows what it can do to help, and can take a positive action online. “Click to email a salesperson” isn’t going to cut it. “Click to chat with a live person” is much better. “Click to buy” is even better. “Click to recommend this site to your friends,” however, may be the best outcome.

Based on the goals you identified in your engagement plan, design interactions that explain the participation options, and entice people to get involved, right now.

The old saw that salespeople must practice ABC — Always Be Closing — is applicable to online as well. But what it means to close may be different. If you’re that obnoxious sales guy always asking, “Are you ready to buy now? How about now? Now?” you’re not going to be successful online.

While it doesn’t pay to be obnoxious, you also don’t want to be shy. It’s best online to give before asking, and it’s also best to gradually draw your audience in to a more intimate relationship.

Perhaps you start off by offering information on your business, and then ask for a small commitment, like entering an email address to receive a white paper, or a newsletter, or a bumper sticker. Then perhaps you ask them to email their friends about your social site. Later you may ask them to sign up for a newsletter, or come to an event, or take action in some other small way. It’s a conversation. It’s relationship building, and you don’t want to go too fast, yet at the same time you want to enable those who are really excited to proceed at a faster pace.

How you ask and what you ask for at what time is more art than science. You can take your learning from offline efforts and try to apply it online. Just be sure you keep your ears open. Ask those you’re involving how they’d like the relationship to progress, and don’t fall into the offline ways of constantly pushing messages as a passive audience.

Regardless of your other online goals, most businesses share a common goal: Increase sales. Buying online now has a long history, and is rather sophisticated and well-developed. Social media definitely offers new ways to reach and inform prospective customers while drawing them into an ever-more-intimate relationship with your business. We take a look at this topic in the following post.

Next up: Social Media Relationship Stages


Ask for the Commitment on Social Media is the 32nd in a series of excerpts from our book, Be a Person: the Social Operating Manual for Enterprises (itself part of a series for different audiences). At this rate it’ll be a long time before we get through all 430 pages, but luckily, if you’re impatient, the book is available in paper form at http://bit.ly/OrderBeAPerson and you can save $5 using Coupon Code 62YTRFCV

See the previous posts What is Social Media?, Social Sites Defined, Why Social Media? How is Social Media Relevant to Business? First Steps Toward a Social Media Strategy, and Decide What Your Business Will Do About Social Computing, pt. 1


Your First Social Media Contributions

Your First Social Media Contributions

In our previous post, Social Media Engagement Plan Contents, we laid out a suggested outline for your engagement plan. In this post, we talk about your first social media contributions.

RenegadeAttributionShare AlikeSome rights reserved by GollyGForce

Your First Contributions

Before considering a large undertaking such as modifying your site with social media features or creating a do-it-yourself standalone social media site, dip your toe in the water and gauge the tenor of your community. After you’ve listened for an extended period, you can start engaging by posting on existing communities. Here are a few suggestions for your first contributions:

  • Be low-risk, for example, by posting interesting, non-controversial news, comments, or events
  • Know who the champions are in your community and acknowledge them visibly, perhaps by commenting on their posts
  • Share professional/personal information
  • Share a professional problem and ask if somebody has the same problems/interests
  • Highlight content from well-established community members more often than content you create. You’ll build good will.
  • Refresh your content often, but not TOO often: Performing A/B split content analysis using Google Analytics can help you figure out how often

Once you’re a familiar face, consider asking the community to help you design your enterprise’s social media presence. If appropriate (and your legal counsel approves), you can conduct contests that invite ideas and let other members help judge them. This is a technique called crowdsourcing (see bit.ly/cpyFhG for more information), and it is an effective way to encourage people to not only contribute ideas, but to take a stake in them.

Keep It Fresh

Change the content on your social media sites regularly. How you define regularly depends on your community, but you should shoot for at least weekly updates. The surest way to ensure the death of a community site is to let it get stale. This goes for the content you generate, and the discussion and other material your members generate. Mix it up. Give people a reason to come back, or to follow your feed, or to seek you out wherever you are.

Promote the Community via Other Venues

Social media should not exist in a vacuum, or even only online. Feature your social media presence in your newsletter, in your advertising, at your events, anywhere you’re doing public relations or marketing.

Even if you decide to focus on social features of your enterprise’s Website, or on a standalone social networking site that you build, also engage members and donors where they are (Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, MySpace, and YouTube)

And of course, don’t forget to promote your social media activities on traditional media.

Synergistic Promotion Activities

We’ve said previously that you shouldn’t stop doing anything you’re currently doing just because you’ve started to use social media. Even more important: Fold your social media efforts into your other efforts so they reinforce one another. Here are some ideas along those lines.

  • Social network outreach— If you have your own community or are sponsoring online events,  use social networks like Facebook, Twitter and MySpace to promote your activities and gather feedback
    • Blog outreach — Create a plan to involve influential bloggers and get them to write about your organization. Be sure to designate someone to follow and engage bloggers. Read Fanscape and the Word of Mouth Marketing Association’s white paper, Pitching to Bloggers.[1]
    • Email — Identify e-mail lists you can encourage to pass your message on. Ask staff, managers, and board to consider informing their personal contacts about your social computing efforts.
    • Personal networks — Ask staff, managers, community members and supporters to tell their personal networks (online and offline) about your social media activities
  • Traditional media outreach — Fold in links to your social media presence and promote your online events along with your offline events. Ensure that your current media personnel are well-versed in what you’re doing online.
    • Online ads — Although online advertising is no longer as effective as it once was, you may still want to leverage it. Consider buying ads on search engines, such as Google AdWords, and ads on Facebook, LinkedIn and other social sites. Determine whether you will you hire professionals to produce the creative and manage the ad buy.
    • Offline ads — How will you promote via broadcast advertising? Will you do print ads — even if it’s just including your URL in another ad for your enterprise or brand?
    • Direct mail — If you do regular mailings, integrate your online messaging and URLs
    • Collateral — If you produce written materials or trinkets, be sure to promote your social media presence
  • Partnerships — Ask partners to spread the word to their customers, members, or constituencies
  • Other established channels — Consider telling your social media story wherever you communicate with people, for example, your telephone hold music

Next up: Ask for the Commitment on Social Media


Your First Social Media Contributions is the 31st in a series of excerpts from our book, Be a Person: the Social Operating Manual for Enterprises (itself part of a series for different audiences). At this rate it’ll be a long time before we get through all 430 pages, but luckily, if you’re impatient, the book is available in paper form at http://bit.ly/OrderBeAPerson and you can save $5 using Coupon Code 62YTRFCV

See the previous posts What is Social Media?, Social Sites Defined, Why Social Media? How is Social Media Relevant to Business? First Steps Toward a Social Media Strategy, and Decide What Your Business Will Do About Social Computing, pt. 1


[1]The Word of Mouth Marketing Association’s white paper, Pitching to Bloggers: bit.ly/wW6CXk
Social Media Engagement Plan Contents

Social Media Engagement Plan Contents

In our previous post, Social Media Engagement on Your Site, we took a look getting our Website ready for launch your engagement plan. In this post, we detail the contents of your engagement planning document.

NoahAttributionShare AlikeSome rights reserved by nedrichards

Engagement Plan Contents

After doing the thinking and your preliminary goal and audience identification, you’re ready to create the engagement plan. The following are questions you should ask, as well as other recommended elements your engagement plan should include:

  • Reasons for Using Social Media
    • What do you have to offer?
    • What problem are you trying to solve (reaching an audience, encouraging evangelism, improving sales)?
    • Why are you using social media to accomplish your goal?
  • Social Media Approach
    • There are three basic approaches to using social media. Lay out how you’ll use them, singly, in combination, or simultaneously:
      • Participate where conversations are already happening (for example on Facebook, Google+, YouTube, or Twitter)
      • Use, enhance, or create social media aspects of your existing Website
      • Create new a social network that stands alone — using, for example, Ning or other white-box social network software to create an online venue that you control
  • Content Plan
    • What kind of content will you publish?
    • What are the style guidelines for content creation?
    • What are the rules of engagement with community members?
    • Will you syndicate content from/to other sites? If so, where, how, and why?
  • Design Plan
    • Determine your design parameters
      • How will the site look?
      • How will it work?
      • What features will it have?
    • Create a usability test plan
  • Release Plan
    • Avoid a single big-bang release; release incrementally
    • Start small
    • Coordinate final release with marketing efforts
  • Resource Plan
    • Identify/assign resources, including writers and a community manager
    • Create the required internal processes for ensuring adequate staffing
    • Create a budget for start up and the first two years
    • Indicate supporters and what they will contribute
  • Training Plan
    • Do a social media readiness assessment
    • Create a plan to fill the gaps
    • Ensure advanced social media training for staff assigned
    • Assess the amount of culture change involved in using social media and create change management plans to address
    • Recruit real users and have a professional do a test
    • Start with low-risk contributions, for example, by posting to existing social networking sites
  • Metrics Plan
    • What does success look like?
    • What measures will tell you your progress toward your goals?
    • What success factors are the most important?
    • What metrics assess those factors best?
    • How will you collect these metrics?
    • What metrics are related and should be analyzed together?
    • What kind of analyses are valid for the metrics?
    • How reliable are the metrics?
    • How reliable is the analysis? What specific tools will you use to measure activity and community engagement?
    • What corrective actions are triggered when metrics are bad?
  • Outreach/Promotion Plan
    • How will you promote online?
    • What bloggers/online influentials will you target for cross promotion?
    • How will you fold the social media message into your traditional marketing efforts?
  • Listening Strategy
    • How will you monitor what others are saying about you?
    • How will you engage them?
    • What will you do about negatives?
  • Community Management Plan
    • Communities require care and feeding. Determine who is responsible, their duties, and the support they’ll need.
    • Develop contingency plans for foreseeable problems such as dealing with trolls (excessively disruptive, negative, or argumentative community members)

These sections should get you started on your plan.

Next up: Your First Social Media Contributions


Create Your Social Media Engagement Plan is the 30th in a series of excerpts from our book, Be a Person: the Social Operating Manual for Enterprises (itself part of a series for different audiences). At this rate it’ll be a long time before we get through all 430 pages, but luckily, if you’re impatient, the book is available in paper form at http://bit.ly/OrderBeAPerson and you can save $5 using Coupon Code 62YTRFCV

See the previous posts What is Social Media?, Social Sites Defined, Why Social Media? How is Social Media Relevant to Business? First Steps Toward a Social Media Strategy, and Decide What Your Business Will Do About Social Computing, pt. 1


Social Media Engagement on Your Site

Social Media Engagement on Your Site

In our previous post, Design Effective Social Media Community Processes, we examined some do’s and don’ts of community processes.  In this post, we give some tips on modifying your current Web site to be ready for social media.

Engagement on Your Site

Embracing social media will almost inevitably require you to make changes to your enterprise’s current Website. Thus it’s a good time to think about how your current site is organized, how effective it is, and how your site’s visitors are  going to find your social networking features.

RenegadeAttributionShare AlikeSome rights reserved by TORLEY

Try to avoid the corporate underpants approach. The term, apparently coined by user experience con­sult­ant Tamara Adlin, refers to sites that are organized completely around the structure of the enterprise, rather than in a way that will satisfy the goals and interests of the site’s visitors. You’ll know you’re showing your corporate underpants, Adlin says, “when your org chart shows up in the primary navigation of your Website.”[1]

Do your site’s visitors really want to know your enterprise is organized into departments, or regions, or brands and sub-brands? Why should they care?

Think about why a person would come to your social media site (OK, any of your sites).

Adlin gives an example of a travel site: “We knew we wanted to go on a ‘trip’ or ‘travel somewhere’ [ . . . ] but, when we arrived on the site, we just accepted that ‘flights’ and ‘hotels’ and ‘cars’ should be thought of, and booked, separately.”[2]

What do your visitors want? Give it to them quickly and plainly. You only have 10 seconds.[3]

How you do this depends on your business. A consumer packaged goods company is going to have a different approach than medical device business, or a bank. But let’s say you have several marketing initiatives. You could organize your community site around these initiatives, with special areas for each. Always make sure you put somebody in charge of responding to questions or comments in each of the sections. People always feel better if they can get a real human to respond to them.

There’s lots more to say about renovating your current site, but it’s beyond the scope of this post. Suffice it to say that if you think you can just graft a blog onto your existing site, you may find that nobody visits it, and conclude that social media doesn’t work. It’s better to integrate social media functions into the fabric of your site, and while you’re at it, take the time to examine your assumptions about the effectiv­eness of your current site.

Next up: Social Media Engagement Plan Contents


Social Media Engagement on Your Site is the 29th in a series of excerpts from our book, Be a Person: the Social Media Operating Manual for Enterprises (itself part of a series for different audiences). At this rate it’ll be a long time before we get through all 430 pages, but luckily, if you’re impatient, the book is available in paper form at http://bit.ly/OrderBeAPerson and you can save $5 using Coupon Code 62YTRFCV

See the previous posts What is Social Media?Social Sites DefinedWhy Social Media? How is Social Media Relevant to Business? First Steps Toward a Social Media Strategy, and Decide What Your Business Will Do About Social Computing, pt. 1


[1] Hide Your Corporate Underpants — Using Personas in UX Design: bit.ly/drZ0fG

[2] Process Pantylines: Why SEO and UX should share a cubicle: bit.ly/d3sb6j

[3] You have only 10 seconds to make a good first impression: bit.ly/cTz8sV


How Can a Renegade Social Network Survive?

In the previous post, Even the Paranoid Have Enemies: Social Media and Law Enforcement, we examined some good reasons why the Occupy movement might want their own network, which they announced via a manifesto entitled The Global Square: Towards an Online Platform for the Occupy Movement. In this post, we examine how this effort could represent a threat to the Facebook social network hegemony and ignite a fragmentation movement for other niche groups to create their own networks.

RenegadeAttributionSome rights reserved by throwthedamnthing

Facebook is a social media goliath with more than 900 million users and growing by 10 million a month. According to Jeff Bullas, “One in every 13 people on Earth is on Facebook. More than 2.5 million websites have integrated with Facebook, including over 80 of comScore’s U.S. Top 100 websites and over half of comScore’s Global Top 100 websites.”

So what’s to worry?

If we’ve learned anything from social media history (I’m looking at you guys, Friendster and MySpace) it’s that things can change very quickly. The buzz dissipates and the crowd moves on to the next bright shiny thing. Facebook, Google, YouTube, LinkedIn and Twitter all look pretty stable right now but one false move, and their lead could evaporate.

Thinking conventionally about the threat to the established commercial social networking sites, one might project that if these site will fall, it would be because they were supplanted by an upstart like Google+ that would attract the hundreds of millions to itself like a massive black hole.

But it could be that the threat might be from a constellation of more-niche networks like Global Square where millions of members who are dissatisfied with existing choices splinter into dozens or hundreds of specialty social sites.

The Global Square manifesto enumerates other reasons beyond privacy for needing a special social network:

While Facebook and Twitter have been very helpful for disseminating basic information and aiding mass mobilization, they do not provide us with the tools for extending our participatory model of decision-making beyond the direct reach of the assemblies and up to the global level. What we need, at this point, is a platform that allows us to radically democratize our global organizational efforts. In addition to the local squares, we now need a global square where people of all nations can come together as equals to participate in the coordination of collective actions and the formulation of common goals and aspirations.

OK, you say, but how many people are this radical? Granted, the majority probably aren’t. But if you read between the lines of this paragraph you see that some of the current social network shortcomings might be shared by others, including corporations.

The big social networks don’t currently provide:

  • Efficient collaboration— I personally have been waiting for this one. Sure, you can use Google Docs to collaborate on a document, but this is very rudimentary. You can use tools such as WebEx and GoToMeeting to show a common view to lots of people. You can use Twitter or Instant Messaging or Skype to create a real-time conferences. But cobbling these platforms together is unsatisfying and comprehensive sharing suites provided by the likes of Cisco are premium-priced.

What if Global Square solves this problem on their way to “extending our participatory model of decision-making beyond the direct reach of the assemblies and up to the global level?”

  • Distributed decision-making — Global Square wants to enable the “leaderless” distributed model that runs Occupy events. We’ve seen similar types of coalescence in social media via flash mobs, the so-called “smash and grab” flash mobs such as the one that terrorized shoppers at the Mall of America, and even in Groupon’s business model.

What if Global Square takes us all the way to a true distributed decision-making model? Such a model was envisioned in John Brunner’s classic, Shockwave Rider in which Delphi pools used the wisdom of crowds by enabling citizens to bet on important issues with the government making policy based on the results. Using prediction markets is not that far-fetched. The Bush administration’s John Poindexter’s Policy Analysis Market concept was abandoned (so they say) as a way to predict terrorist attacks. Embedding such markets in a social network to guide all kinds of decision-making is certainly feasible, and may well be an attractive feature to non-radicals.

  • Real-time language translation— For Global Square to achieve “a global square where people of all nations can come together as equals to participate in the coordination of collective actions and the formulation of common goals and aspirations” people speaking different languages need to be able to converse in real-time. This implies integration of a fast real-time translation capability which is already in use in some social networks.

Wouldn’t this capability be attractive to businesses and other multi-national organizations?

  • Project management — Organizing an Occupy protest, especially in a decentralized organization, requires good project management. Organizing a worldwide protest requires management and coordination on a large scale. In addition, a centralized inventory of Occupy assets worldwide would be required for Global Square’s mission.

This is another feature that may prove quite attractive to businesses and other multi-national organizations.

  • Anonymous alternative to the social graph — Facebook introduced their Social Graph as a means for users to log in to other sites using Facebook credentials. This has two effects. It enables many sites to streamline their login procedures, and it also allows external sites access to some or all of a Facebook user’s information. In addition, use of social graph on shared computers can be problematic, as a user’s login session can persist after they’ve left the computer. Although the manifesto doesn’t specifically call for an anonymous single sign-on, it seems clear that a network concerned with preventing user information from falling into law enforcement or governmental hands would require an anonymous way for users to log in, and that method would undoubtedly be extended to other participating networks.

Many social media users are concerned with privacy matters and might be attracted to networks that offer more control than Facebook.

If Global Square succeeds in building their network with these features, their effort could embolden others to challenge the status quo by adopting their feature set. If Global Square takes the step of offering their code via an Open Source license, adoption by current or new social networks would be assured.

All of this would feed into a rapidly accelerating trend called the Web of One. With all the personalization of users’ experience — extending from Google localization and personalization to the nichification of TV news represented by Fox News and MSNBC — users can increasingly cocoon themselves into a self-referential personalized world where they only experience things that they already know they’ll like.

No matter what you think of this trend, it is unmistakable. And this might be the gale force driving the dismantling of the Facebook empire through the proliferation of Global-Square-like niche networks.

Or not. The only thing we know for sure is that size does not necessarily ensure survival, online or in the real world. Remember, only General Electric remains of the original 1896 Dow Jones index, and Ford is the only intact company among the top 100 corporations from 1900. And so the question that titles this post should be transformed as How Can the Current Social Networks Survive?

Even the Paranoid Have Enemies: Social Media and Law Enforcement

Even the Paranoid Have Enemies: Social Media and Law Enforcement

In the previous post, You Say You Want a Revolution(ary) Social Network?, we examined why the Occupy movement wants their own network, which they announced via a manifesto entitled The Global Square: Towards an Online Platform for the Occupy Movement. In this post, we examine some reasons why Occupy feels they need to abandon existing social networks and build their own.

Social Media and Law EnforcementAttributionShare AlikeSome rights reserved by redtimmy

Ed Knutson, a web and mobile app developer who joined a team of activist-geeks redesigning social networking for the era of global protest, quoted in a Wired magazine article, said “I don’t want to say we’re making our own Facebook. But, we’re making our own Facebook. “We don’t want to trust Facebook with private messages among activists.”

There is good reason for dissident movements to mistrust commercial, mainstream social networks. Here are some examples:

  • Between September 2008 and October 2009, Sprint Nextel provided law enforcement agencies with customer GPS location information more than 8 million times
  • In December 2010, the U.S. district court in Alexandria, Virginia, granted an order asking Twitter to disclose information connected to four WikiLeaks-related accounts
  • Governments in Egypt, Tunisia, Syria, Libya, Iran, and others have shut down, restricted use, and mined social networks for information on dissidents
  • A Reuters review of the Westlaw legal database found that federal judges authorized at least two dozen warrants to search individuals’ Facebook accounts since 2008. Many requested a personal data such as messages, status updates, links to videos and photographs, calendars of future and past events, “Wall postings” and “rejected Friend requests.”
  • In 2010 Google complied with 94 percent of law enforcement requests for personal data, including search history. In six months, Google reported receiving 4,601 requests for data from the U.S. government. Google also reported an increase of 29 percent in the number of US requests in the first six months of 2011 compared to the previous reporting period.
  • Twitter released a subpoena they received from the Suffolk County Massachusetts District Attorney’s Office for information on user @P0isAn0N, a popular conspiracy blogger who calls himself Guido Fawkes.

The Electronic Frontier Foundation has posted an Excel file of the various social networks’ privacy policies, which generally say they will cooperate with law enforcement without notifying users. Clearly, the Occupy movement has reason to worry that such tactics may be used against lawful activities they may indulge in.

But can such a network be built and survive in the long run? That’s the subject of the next post, How Can a Renegade Social Network Survive?